The Marxist Lie of Labor

September 7, 2017
2 mins read

Labor sucks. Working is a pain in the butt. It really is a just a means to an end. By our labor, we earn our daily bread. This is the ironclad law of life on Earth as set by the God of Heaven as part of Adam’s punishment that we all get for free.
It goes without saying, Marx was wrong about nearly everything he penned. One of his most egregious errors was the flap about the theory of alienation. In a nutshell, the German raised work to be the highest state of being and demanded that man should find himself in his work and nowhere else. Wholeness could only come from worshipping the labor of his hands.

Mises covered this aptly in Human Action. After describing the generalities of labor he hits on the core concept: the disutility of labor. Read it here“Disutility of labor is the discomfort, uneasiness, inconvenience or pain inherent in human effort. Because of this quality men regard labor as a burden and prefer leisure to toil or labor.”
You might like your job, but I dare you to look me in the eye and say you click your heels in unbridled joy over the prospect of working at your job.
We work to mediate gratification. The pleasure of a job well done is real. The wages we earn in exchange of our labor are real. The necessities we can buy from those wages or the wants we can fulfill are real.
But if you buy into the Marxist lie about labor, you set your feet on a path where you swallow all sorts of errant nonsense.

“The worker begins to hate his work if he becomes convinced that what makes him submit to the disutility of labor is not his own higher valuation of the stipulated compensation, but merely an unfair social system.” – Mises, Human Action.

In other words, you the worker have struck a deal with your current job that for the effort you put in, they will pay you an agreed amount of money according some schedule. You value the wages earned more than the pain labor puts on you. Until you start thinking Marx had something worth listening to, and the man is keeping you down, man.

“Deluded by the slogans of the socialist propagandists, he fails to realize that the disutility of labor is an inexorable fact of human conditions, something ultimately given that cannot be removed by devices or methods of social organization. He falls prey to the Marxian fallacy that in a socialist commonwealth work will arouse not pain but pleasure.” – Mises, Ibid.

This is why, after socialism fails, the socialist propagandists have to say it wasn’t real socialism. Their worldview is based on a lie about labor and they have to keep lying in order to keep their worldview from crumbling.
It has to be that way. Anything else and the Marxist is no longer a Marxist and has been cast into the cold light of reality and truth, the two things that cannot care one iota about your feelings on the matter.
Mises doesn’t leave us with just the insight of why Marxism is fraudulent from the ground up, he also explains a way forward out of the mechanical materialism.

“To be joyful in the performance of one’s tasks and in overcoming the disutility of labor makes people cheerful and strengthens their energies and vital forces.” – Mises, Ibid.

And that key to making work work is something the Marxists will always bury in propaganda. Finding joy despite the labor is what helps cleanse the soul. It’s a maxim of the Christian, the Man of the West, that despite the hardship involved we will not let that define our attitude.


  1. “the Marxian fallacy that in a socialist commonwealth work will arouse not pain but pleasure…”
    It goes right back to Genesis 3:19: “By the sweat of your brow you will eat your food until you return to the ground, since from it you were taken; for dust you are and to dust you will return.”
    There was always work; Adam was told to keep the Garden before he screwed everything up. But work did not always include frustration, futility, danger, all that stuff that Marxists promise to get rid of if only you’ll convert to their goofy religion. Someday it will be pleasurable again, but not because of anything Marx did.

  2. As I sit and read this from my lunch break from “work”, it almost does sound good. The idea that the remainder of my work day could be so satisfying that I thought of nothing else and longed to return. Ahh, the bliss… Why is it, then, I cant wait to get out of here and go fishing??
    HAHA, And all this while i really do enjoy my job…

    • “The idea that the remainder of my work day could be so satisfying that I thought of nothing else and longed to return.”
      There’s the lie. The disutility of work cannot be banished.
      “Why is it, then, I cant wait to get out of here and go fishing??”
      Because that’s one of the reasons you work. 🙂 you value the ability to go fishing more than work, so you’ll gladly trade some of your time and effort to be able to go fishing (and pay the bills, and buy food, etc)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Support Men Of The West

Previous Story

The Seventieth Week of Daniel – Part 3

Next Story

Global Warming Makes Perfect Sense

Latest from Culture

10 Westerns You Should See

Westerns. I love Western movies. Hold on to your 10-gallon hats, because I’m doing a speedrun through 10 reviews. “Once Upon A Time In The West” Great show, skirts right to the
Go toTop